Maybelline Falsies vs One by One vs Colossal?

Okay well i am trying to decide what mascara to get because i am entering high school and i would like to put on makeup. What mascara should i get from those three... I have long eyelashes the are straight and i need a mascara the can hold a curl (I will curl my eyelashes first then apply the mascara)...also should i get waterproof, washable, or the regular mascara?